Subject: Hispec wins patent case – Ei (Aico) patent ruled invalid
Most, if not all, of the market will be aware that since summer 2024 Hispec has been in a legal dispute with Ei Technology, (“Ei”) which claimed we were infringing one of its patents in the UK.
We believe that until a Court decides the issue, the existence of disputes like this should not be used to impact customer perception or cause uncertainty in the market. However, throughout these proceedings Ei and its UK subsidiary, Aico, chose to make the claim very public, making sure that the market was made aware of the proceedings and exaggerate their alleged potential impact.
Now that we have a judgment from the Court, we want the whole market to hear the outcome just as clearly: Hispec has won.
Today the High Court ruled that Ei’s patent is invalid on multiple grounds. The court found it was not new, and that it was obvious in light of an earlier patent application.
The High Court also found that Ei’s conduct amounted to an abuse of process, by saying one thing to get its patent granted by the patent office and the opposite in the High Court.
This is a clear win for Hispec, and for the housing providers, contractors and wholesalers who want genuine choice in the products they fit. Our customers can keep buying, specifying and fitting Hispec alarms with complete confidence.
While we were always very confident that the patent was invalid, this has been a long and difficult process, particularly when going up against a considerably larger competitor. We thank our loyal customers, who have stuck by us and not listened to the noise in the market.
We would also like to place on record our thanks to our lawyers, Gowling WLG, and in particular Michael Carter, Alex Driver and Megan Wiggin, and to our barristers, Hugo Cuddigan KC and Mitchell Beebe.
There are still some consequential matters that need to be resolved by the High Court, such as Ei’s payment towards Hispec’s costs. We therefore won’t be commenting further at this stage.
Ends





